Kerala Government's Decision to Ban Alcohol in Kerala!
by Elizabeth Menon
Shutting Down Bars or Ban on Alcohol is not the Answer!
Kerala government has decided to close all 730 bars in the state, allowing only five-star hotels to have the bars from April 2015 – 418 bars have been closed already since April and licence for the 312 bars will not be renewed after 31 March2015. Kerala State Beverages Corporation (KSBC) runs 337 liquor shops, open seven days a week, each liquor shop catering for around an amazing 80,000 clients also would be phased out! Kerala consumes 16% of India's total liquor and has the country’s highest per capita consumption of alcohol at 8.3 litres per year taking over that of Punjab and Haryana, and double the national figure of four litres/year! It is estimated that more than 40% of revenue come from alcohol, both from KSBC and private sector! One must understand here that the per capita consumption rate of 8.3 litres/year is calculated in relation to the total population that includes women and children, most of whom do not consume the stuff and therefore, the actual rate would be even much higher! It is then, not surprising that the incidence of liver failure following cirrhosis liver is rather high, and not to forget domestic violence and alcohol related divorces! Alcohol in excess is detrimental for health and there is no argument against its ill effects, but closing the bars in hotels or ban on liquor is not the answer for that -- this would only increase the flow of illicit toxic liquor into the community, which would cause blindness and death!
Domestic violence, suicide and poverty due to excessive drinking is another side of the coin, but a ban will not stop it, as those who need the drink will find the toxic liquor from back-streets, which would be more dangerous -- the buyers and the sellers going underground! People should be made aware of the dangers of excessive drinking -- a glass of wine a day is accepted to be good and the incidence of heart disease is known to be less in Italy where people do have a drink with their meal, but that does not mean that one should drink it like the cattle do -- a drink is meant to be sipped slowly and not drink in one gulp as shown in some films! The awareness among people to drink in moderation is what is needed and to avoid drinking the illicit toxic drink that can cause all sorts of damage, and also to avoid drink-driving!
There are lot of people around the world, even among the elite and high-society who do not drink, but it is quite the done thing to have a drink with one's meal, or during a social occasion, which does not make one an alcoholic! And there are few who like a shot of brandy or whiskey in the evening and they too would find it difficult to get it or be forced to buy it in the black market, and these people also are not alcoholics! We are living in the 21st century, and we should be aware of the financial aspects too, as money for the public services do not drop from the sky; the revenue comes from all sorts and tourism makes a big part! Most tourists would like to have a drink when they are on holiday and when they know that they can't have a drink, they would think twice before coming to Kerala – students and people on a budget form the majority of tourists who couldn't afford the 'Five-star facilities'! And also the Government needs money for education, salary, pension, etc and they would have to increase the tax or the price of commodities to raise the money for its functioning, or cut back on benefits, and eventually the people will have to bear the brunt of it all. These are some of the facts one need to consider before barging on a scheme like putting a ban on alcohol! People work very hard all their life and it is the Pension, Provident fund, etc, that give a bit of comfortable living once they retire and that should never be touched, and even thinking about stopping these is unpardonable!
'Alcoholism' is an addiction that needs 'Treatment and rehabilitation', like any other addiction, and 'Shutting down Bars' is not the answer! Usually there are underlying causes for this dreadful condition and what they need is help and compassion and majority of them could be treated, but it is generally considered a lifelong process, which is what the 'Treatment Centres' are doing even worldwide, with good results -- we have come a long way in treating this and similar conditions! There are 28 such 'De-addiction and Drug and alcohol rehabilitation Centres' in Kerala --'Navajeeva Kendram' in Malayalappuzha in Pathanamthitta District is just one example! There is only one Ayurvedic centre in Kerala, 'Sanjo Sadan Ayurvedic De-Addiction Cum Rehabilitation Centre, Anandapuram' in Irinjalakkuda -- this centre alone has treated more than 1600 addicts! All these centres are very highly rated and well known for their success in treating those with Drug and Alcohol addictions. There is a great variety of treatment options, such as integrated treatment, counselling, residential rehab, Alcoholic Anonymous and Narcotic Anonymous Groups (AA and NA Groups),etc. The treatment in most of these Centres has a holistic approach to the healing of the alcoholics and drug addicts. The treatment focuses to identify and change the core issue or problem which blocks the person to lead a healthy happy life.
The treatment is based on the concept of considering addiction as a disorder, which may have its roots in childhood, parenting, experiences or behaviour learning, hereditary factors and personality factors.The treatment is based on the concept of considering addiction as a disorder, which may have its roots in childhood, parenting, experiences or behaviour learning, hereditary factors and personality factors.The treatment program begins with minimum 15 days residential program, during which time, the patient goes through medication for withdrawals, psycho education, assessment, group therapy, skill training, yoga, meditation and prayer, relaxation therapy, counselling, psycho therapy, hypnotherapy and family therapy. The government should be providing financial help for these centres and promote awareness of the dangers of alcoholism and the options available at these Centres where one could get help, as most people are not aware of this facility!
There are so many other things that the government should be spending their time, like protecting women and children from the rapists and trafficking, stopping corruption, implementing the existing law of wearing seat belts by all passengers in a car and helmets for the two-wheelers to prevent deaths, improving roads, increasing old age pension, providing benefits for the disabled, etc! I don't want anyone to think that I support the 'Liquor lobby': 'I don't', and I don't drink either! It is ideal if one could avoid all that is harmful, but we don't live in an ideal world, and one should know one's own limitation (“Man must know his limitations', as in the famous quote!) and learn to stop when that limit is reached – drinking in moderation, unless alcohol is medically advised against, should be the motto for those who like a drink! The public also should take some responsibility for their welfare and seriously think about curtailing their desire to get immersed in alcohol or go on a binge at weekends or during festivals! It is the public awareness regarding the hazardous aspects of alcohol that should be promoted and not a 'Ban on alcohol', which will have dire consequences at various levels, including the increase in the underground selling of illicit toxic alcohol that kills, bringing on death and blindness on a massive scale, while those with money buying the stuff in the black market!! Ban is not the answer, which will only flourish the black market and the sellers in the Underground and one needs to think logically about all aspects before bringing on the 'Ban'!